2026 Report
Average Group Health Insurance Lead Conversion Rates: 2026 Report
How many group health leads become written groups, by lead source, and why the renewal calendar moves the rate as much as the source does.
A conversion means an employer group that gets written, measured from the first sales conversation. Quote requests alone don’t count. For brokers, this rate times commission value is what any lead source is worth.
Quick answer: Held screened appointments with employers convert at 15–22%. Referral introductions convert at 30–48%, employer web inquiries at 8–14%, paid search at 5–9%, and shared or multi-quoted leads at 2–5%.
Table 1: Group health lead conversion rates by source
| Lead source | Conversion rate | Why it runs where it does |
|---|---|---|
| Referral introductions (CPAs, attorneys) | 30–48% | The trust arrives with the meeting; capped by partner network size |
| Screened appointments (held) | 15–22% | Decision-maker meetings with interest verified |
| Employer web inquiries | 8–14% | An employer filling out a benefits form has a renewal problem now |
| Paid search | 5–9% | $30–$60 clicks, heavy comparison shopping |
| Shared / multi-quoted leads | 2–5% | Several brokers quoting one group; wins come from commission cuts |
Table 2: The renewal calendar effect
Group sales run on renewal dates. The same lead source converts differently by quarter, because employers shop when renewals hurt. Volume and conversion both follow this calendar.
| Window | What happens | How to play it |
|---|---|---|
| September–December | January renewals shop; the year’s peak | Peak lead volume; buy and book heaviest here |
| January–March | Post-renewal regret after increases land | Prospect the unhappy; strong conversion on fresh pain |
| April–August | Off-cycle renewals only | Steady but thinner; build the pipeline for Q4 |
| 60–120 days pre-renewal | The decision window for any group | Leads timed to this window convert at the top of every band |
A mediocre source timed to the renewal window beats a great source timed wrong. Brokers who buy flat monthly volume all year waste summer budget the Q4 rush needed.
Table 3: Conversion by group size
Group size decides whether an owner or a committee is on the other side of the table. Held appointments convert accordingly.
| Group size | Conversion rate | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 2–9 lives | 17–22% | Owner-decided; fastest cycle |
| 10–24 lives | 15–22% | The core market; the headline band |
| 25–49 lives | 13–18% | HR and finance both weigh in |
| 50+ lives | 11–16% | Broker RFPs and incumbent defenses |
What these rates mean for a benefits practice
Run the commission math before judging any rate. A 25-life group pays roughly $6,900–$8,100 a year in commission and renews for years, so even a 15% conversion on appointments pays back fast. The full cost math is in our group health CAC report and group health lead cost benchmarks.
And respond in minutes, not hours. An employer with a renewal problem filled out more than one form, and the first broker in the conversation frames it.
Frequently asked questions
- What is a good conversion rate for group health insurance leads?
- 15-22% on held screened appointments and 8-14% on employer web inquiries. Referral introductions run 30-48%, paid search 5-9%, and shared leads 2-5%.
- Why does the renewal calendar matter so much?
- Employers shop benefits when renewals hurt, mostly September through December for January renewals. The same lead source converts at the top of its band inside the 60-120 day pre-renewal window and near the bottom outside it.
- Do shared group health leads ever make sense?
- Rarely as a core source. At 2-5% conversion with several brokers quoting the same group, wins usually come from cutting commission, which poisons the economics of the book.
-
Sources & methodology
- About Upcision: We have run outbound campaigns across 14 verticals since 2019, for clients ranging from SMB to Fortune 500. Figures on this page combine our campaign experience with published group health insurance industry benchmarks.
- Channel benchmarks: Upcision published benchmark series on lead costs, close rates, and show rates.
- PDF copy: Want this report as a PDF? Contact us through upcision.com and we’ll send it over.
- Citing this page: Writers are welcome to cite these figures with attribution to Upcision Research and a link to this page.
